Best Bagel Shops in New Jersey!

There’s no doubt that New Jersey has a lot of competition for who has the best bagels. The truth is that there’s so many that it’s almost hard to keep track! If you’re looking for a good bagel, but you’re overwhelmed with options, then you’re in luck! We are here to give you the inside scoop on our favorite bagel shops in New Jersey!

Boxcar Bagels & Deli

These hand-rolled, water-boiled and every-morning-freshly baked bagels have been made the same way for the past 23 years!  Be careful though- these bagels are notorious for being huge! The crispy outside and soft inside topped with some butter or cream cheese ends up being it’s own meal. If you’re looking for a fan favorite, this is the place to go!


The Bagel House

A variety of unique flavors and an endless production of bagels! The Bagel House sells 30 to 40 dozen bagels on weekdays; 60 to 70 dozen on weekends. And they are constantly creating new delicious flavors! Perhaps the most unique flavor is the sun-dried tomato, which is slightly more sweet than salty and quite delicious. This is a must try!


Alfa Bagels

Alfa bagels is famous for their perfect combination of crispy and chewy. A nice crispy outside crust with a soft and chewy middle! On top of their delicious bagel selection, they also offer a food menu, which includes things like burgers and salads. It’s no secret why this place is always busy!

To get more Bagel Shop recommendations, read the full article here!

Compare listings